Home > > Home

ForumsHome

This Question is Answered

1 "helpful" answer available (4 pts)
1 2 3 Previous Next
Post a new topic
38 Replies Last post: Jul 4, 2008 9:31 PM by smallbizinfo

Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How?

Nov 6, 2007 5:01 PM

Click to view ctal108's profile Start-up ctal108 4 posts since
Nov 6, 2007
Hello:

If anyone else has successfully done this I would love to learn how you did it. Our company is a LLC and we have been in business for 2 1/2 years. My partner has been working full time and I'm a part-time partner looking to become full-time in the very near future.

We both have excellent personal credit (750 and above across the three credit bureaus) and we are adamanat about keeping our personal and business credit separate. We have a Dun & Bradstreet profile, and we know that our business credit is being reported to Experiean's business credit center. We have a number of business credit cards, a few vendor lines of credit and we have NEVER been late on any payments. Sounds pretty good right?

Well here's the thing: We're looking to get a bank business line of credit and/or a small business loan and we want to do it based SOLELY on our business credit and not on the combination of our personal credit and the business credit. But everywhere we look we're hitting brick walls! We have spoken to quite a number of lenders and ALL of them require us to give them our SS# instead of being able to use our EIN#. And that means that we'll have a credit inquiry on our record and if we default on the loan that bad credit WILL show up on our personal credit histories.

Do any of you know of any tricks or techniques to be able to get financing SOLELY on your business credit/profile?

Your help and assitance with this is MUCH APPRECIATED!

thanks!
Report as inappropriate
Click to view LUCKIEST's profile SCORE LUCKIEST 7,926 posts since
Aug 6, 2007
1. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 6, 2007 5:21 PM
It is great that you have been in business for 2 and 1/2 years. Hopefully you are in the BLACK
and are showing a profit. It sounds like you are doing all the right moves.
Is there a local SCORE office where you can talk to Counselors. SCORE is FREE and they
can help you with a BUSINESS PLAN and they also talk to local bankers.
I see two problems in what you wrote: When you apply to a bank for a loan, the bank wants to know
it will get repaid and they are looking at your business BUT they want MORE.That is why they want
your personal info as well.
The second problem is that Bank computers talk to each other and if you have applied to many banks,
it raises a FLAG.
Do you have an Accountant?? He can probably help.
Good luck, LUCKIEST.
Click to view ctal108's profile Start-up ctal108 4 posts since
Nov 6, 2007
2. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 6, 2007 5:26 PM
in response to: LUCKIEST
Yes we have been in touch with SCORE and they have helped us with a number of things along the way. But I will tell you that the SBA loans DO require collateral (i.e. - your home, real-estate investments etc...) which is why we are looking for alternatives. You might be thinking: "Well if you really believed in this business you wouldn't be afraid to put your house up for collateral". And to answer that we do believe in the business but we also want the business to be truly a separate entity.

And we haven't applied for ANY loans with the banks. I've just been calling aound to quite a number of lenders and asking questions. So there aren't any unecessary credit inquires in our accounts.
Click to view LUCKIEST's profile SCORE LUCKIEST 7,926 posts since
Aug 6, 2007
3. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 6, 2007 5:35 PM
in response to: ctal108
Glad that SCORE is helping. Banks do not work that way. Banks want there money back,
They DO NOT want your houses, BUT want COLLATERAL.
You know all this. That is the way it is done. Sorry.
LUCKIEST
Click to view Ed O'Gee's profile Mogul Ed O'Gee 215 posts since
Oct 25, 2007
4. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 6, 2007 8:11 PM
Unforunately this will likely be the case with most banks you deal with depending on the size of the loan you want. I will stress that the best thing to do is talk to the banker you deal with most, explain the situation and see if you can get a small line with just the business history with the bank.
Click to view Lighthouse24's profile Mogul Lighthouse24 2,396 posts since
Oct 10, 2007
5. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 7, 2007 12:37 AM

You may already do this, but part of the "trick" seems to be meeting with an experienced commercial loan officer instead of a consumer rep from the bank. Another key seems to be presenting a history of good ratios and retained earnings on your balance sheet -- but exactly how long the history and how good the numbers have to be is a mystery to me. Until a small business is able to meet whatever that "standard" is (or goes public), even a business with strong profits and a good credit history is usually required to have the owner act as a "co-signer" in effect, to guarantee a bank loan or credit line.
Click to view jgoldstein's profile Professional jgoldstein 12 posts since
Oct 10, 2007
6. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 14, 2007 9:52 AM
in response to: Lighthouse24
UNLESS your business has an abundance of liquid (sellable) collateral, banks will require your personal guarantee. If the bank thinks the businesses' collateral could easily be sold to repay the loan, they will not require a personal guarantee.

Their reasoning is that if the business experiences a downturn, you might walk away and leave them holding the bag (a bad debt). Having your personal guarantee improves the likelihood they will be repaid promptly. The personal guarantee demonstrates your commitment to seeing the debt is repaid - and legally makes you responsible for the debt in the event the business doesn't/can't pay up..

By regulation/law, the SBA REQUIRES personal guarantee on their small business loans, and the pledging of your personal residence.

If you were the lender, wouldn't you want this same assurance?

Loans to the business, in the business' name DO NOT show up on your personal credit bureau. The fact that you are a business loan guarantor does not affect your credit bureau score (perhaps it should?).

jg
Click to view ctal108's profile Start-up ctal108 4 posts since
Nov 6, 2007
7. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 14, 2007 9:59 AM
in response to: jgoldstein
I just want to say thank you to everyone who has responded to this question. I spoke to a friend of the family who has about a dozen LLCs (he owns real estate and each property is its own LLC) and he basically said the same thing you've said here. And basically banks are not in the business of helping small businesses -- they're in the business of making money.

thanks!
Click to view Y Not Mag's profile Professional Y Not Mag 23 posts since
Nov 7, 2007
8. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 18, 2007 11:53 AM
in response to: ctal108
Hello this is Jamila Serrant (Owner/Founder of Y-Not Magazine),
I too own an LLC and have to agree with your statement regarding "Banks are not in the Business of helping Small Businesses". Who would have thought until you go into business on your own? I am in the process of searching for funding and have hit the same brick walls. However there is a company that claims to have a step to step approach in helping businesses to establish credit as its own entity (using its own EIN for credit purposes). The URL is: www.b2bcredit.com Please perform a Business check on them with the Better Business Bureau because I did not use their services yet. Lastly, I would love to make contact with you since we are both seeking funding for our LLC. Good Luck to us both.
Click to view ctal108's profile Start-up ctal108 4 posts since
Nov 6, 2007
9. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 18, 2007 12:37 PM
in response to: Y Not Mag
Hi Jamila:

Yes I've seen that site before. And the biggest benefit they provide, at least from what I've read, is that they help you to establish a business credit profile. But honestly if you're willing to read up on this topic you can do that all by yourself. What it takes is having a legally established business entity (e.g. LLC), getting a small business credit card (in the company's name) and then doing to Dun & Bradstreet and getting a free DUNs number. Also call Experian and make sure they have a profile open for your business and if not they will tell you how to make sure one is open for you.

Now for the tricky part: Most, if not all, credit card companies do NOT report to Dun & Bradstreet. Neither do cell phone companies. The trick is to go to your suppliers and find out two things: 1) Will they extend you credit (e.g. NET 15, 30 etc..) AND 2) do they report to any of the credit agencies. Trust me THAT is the hardest part of the process because it is VERY difficult to find a vendor that meets both criteria. And if you DO find one many times they'll extend you the credit if you purchase something like $10,000 worth of merchandise. In my line of business I really have no need of any raw materials that would add up to that much unless I want to buy enough reams of paper to last me until I'm 80.

But remember too that most vendors and lenders require you to have been in business a minimum of two years and sometimes three.

But lets just say that you DO have a decent business credit profile. You'll still have a problem getting a business loan. Why? Because most banks will only loan you up to 15% of your gross income for the year. So let's say your business grossed $200,000 last year -- that means that at most they'll lend you only $30,000 -- not much if you need serious capital to expand.

It is only when your company is grossing $1,000,000 annually will a bank really look at your company as a separate entity. Then you can walk in a get business lines of credit/loans based solely off of your business credit profile. Otherwise you'd better have some other collateral like a home or investment properties.

Chris
Click to view Ed O'Gee's profile Mogul Ed O'Gee 215 posts since
Oct 25, 2007
10. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 18, 2007 12:45 PM
in response to: ctal108
Not sure what banks you guys are working with but most major banks are in the business of helping small businesses. We as business owners mean more in profits to them than the regular person with a checking account. If you have gone to your bank, shown good business credentials and a quality personal and or business credit history and they still won't help you, then it is time to switch banks!

I know personally that both Wamu and bank of america offer business lines of credit where they look at business and/or personal credit histories to make credit decisions.If banks don't lend money, they don't make money, so trust me they are in the business of small business.
Click to view Y Not Mag's profile Professional Y Not Mag 23 posts since
Nov 7, 2007
11. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Nov 24, 2007 5:38 PM
in response to: ctal108
Wow ctal108! Thanks for the in depth information. Did you try WAMU and BOA Like Ed suggested? Please provide me with a follow-up in your quest for funding. I am really interested....

I hope to hear from you soon.

Jamila Serrant (Y-Not Magazine LLC)
Click to view Secretaries's profile Start-up Secretaries 2 posts since
Dec 6, 2007
12. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Dec 7, 2007 8:06 AM
There is a wonderful service available that you may want to look into. They will show you how to seperate and establish personal from business credit. They also guide you on how to establish loans for your business. Watch the presentation in the site. It is phenomenal! Yes there is a small fee, but it is well worth it.
http://www.creditcoach101.com
Click to view LUCKIEST's profile SCORE LUCKIEST 7,926 posts since
Aug 6, 2007
13. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Dec 7, 2007 10:08 AM
in response to: Secretaries
Secretaries, I just tried googling
http://www.creditcoach101.com.
Did not get a match??
Am very interested to learn about your fee SCHEDULE
LUCKIEST
Click to view Lighthouse24's profile Mogul Lighthouse24 2,396 posts since
Oct 10, 2007
14. Re: Separating Personal Credit from Business Credit - How? Dec 7, 2007 11:24 AM

For Luckiest (and whoever else may be interested) I checked out this out, and here's what I found. Anyone, please feel free to post corrections if I misunderstood something.

http://www.creditcoach101.com will take you to a site operated by Corporate Credit Concepts. This company does NOT provide business loans. It sells you, the business owner, a series of credit building programs.

If your credit score is under 680, you must enroll in the Basic Credit Builder Program, where the program "helps" you obtain cash credit (a credit card), mainly by suggesting that you pay your currently overdue bills, and pay your next six months of bills on time. Once you "follow the program" and raise your score to 680 or above, the credit that will be available is estimated at up to $25K, but no minimum amount is guaranteed. The fee for this Basic program is $995 up front and $2,995 once you get a credit card.

Then you move up to the Advanced Credit Builder Program, where the program "helps" you qualify for a corporate line of credit. When you complete this program, the credit that will be available is estimated at up to $100K, but again, no minimum amount is guaranteed. The fee for this Advanced program is $995 up front and $4,995 once you qualify for a line of credit. (This is presumably where the person who posted the original question would begin.)

Then comes the Ultimate Credit Builder Program, with a fee of $995 up front and $6,995 after the program "helps" you establish another company and obtain cash credit for it (more about the reason for that later).

Finally, after two years, you get to the Elite Credit Builder Program, with a fee of $12,995, all up front. This program helps you establish D&B and Paydex files/ratings so you can qualify for up to a $250,000 cash credit line (but as always, this is an estimate, no minimum amount is guaranteed).

So . . . all you need to do is spend $31,000 on these programs and pay all of your bills on time for two years, and you will be able to qualify for a credit card and bank loan! If that sounds like a deal, by all means check it out.

The website frequently mentions that you can get a corporate line of credit in as little as a week. It's true, you can. You purchase what's called a Shelf Aged Corporation -- the attorney in the office next to me creates them and sells them (lots of corporate agencies and attorneys do). The older they are and the better their rating, the more they cost. (It would appear that you'll create one or more of these yourself as part of the Ultimate program.)

Again, if someone has actual experience with these programs and would be able to elaborate on them (or correct anything I might have misunderstood), please post!
1 2 3 Previous Next